inquest

Chapter 5 - The Hidden Thread

"Get out, Evelyn," I ordered, stepping directly between my sister-in-law and the nanny.

Evelyn was shaking. Her icy composure had cracked completely, revealing raw panic underneath. She stared past my shoulder at Elise, whose eyes had widened in alarm as she instinctively tucked the locket back inside her blouse.

"You don't know what you're doing, Julian," Evelyn stammered, her voice shaking with an emotion I couldn't decipher—guilt, fear, or both. "She is dangerous. She shouldn't be anywhere near this house! Near Clara's children!"

"I said get out," I growled, taking a threatening step forward. "Before I have building security escort you to the curb."

Evelyn swallowed hard, threw one last terrified look at Elise, and turned on her heel. The elevator doors closed behind her with a heavy, final clunk, leaving the kitchen in stunned silence.

The girls, sensing the explosive tension, had stopped eating. Maisie dropped her strawberry onto the tray, her little chin trembling.

Elise immediately dropped to her knees between the two highchairs. "Hey, hey," she cooed softly, taking Maisie’s sticky hand in hers. "It's okay, sweet pea. The loud lady just had to catch a train. Look at me. We're making strawberry towers, remember?"

Within ninety seconds, she had deflected the storm. The twins were giggling again, their tiny fingers stacking fruit on their trays.

I stood watching, my mind spinning into overdrive. Evelyn wasn't just offended by Elise's casual appearance. She was terrified of that locket. Clara’s sister had reacted as if she were looking at a ghost—or an executioner.

"Elise," I said quietly. "In my study. Now."

She looked up, her expression guarded. "The girls—"

"Maria will sit with them for five minutes," I said, gesturing to the housekeeper who had just entered the dining room. "Come."

I led her into the study and closed the door firmly. I didn't sit down behind my desk. I stood right in front of her, closing the distance until she had nowhere to look except straight into my eyes.

"Take it out," I demanded.

"Mr. Caruso, please—"

"Take the locket out, Elise. Right now."

Her hands trembled as she reached inside her shirt and pulled the silver pendant over her head. She held it out to me on an open palm.

I took it. The metal was warm from her skin. I turned it over in my fingers. The ivy leaf. The tiny scratch on the bottom edge from when Clara had dropped it on our terrace in Positano. It wasn't a replica. It was Clara's.

"Where did you get this?" I asked, my voice deadly quiet. "And don't lie to me. Evelyn recognized it. I recognize it. It belonged to my wife."

Elise closed her eyes, taking a shuddering breath. When she opened them, tears sparkled in the corners, but her gaze was resolute.

"Clara gave it to me," she whispered.

The room seemed to tilt on its axis.

"That's impossible," I snapped. "Clara died ten months ago. She spent her last six months in and out of Sloan Kettering. You were working for a family in Connecticut."

"I lied about the Hendersons," Elise confessed, a tear finally escaping and tracking down her cheek. "I never worked for them. The agency references were forged. Clara arranged it all before she went into hospice."

I gripped the locket so hard the silver edges bit into my skin. "Why? Why would my wife forge credentials to plant a twenty-four-year-old girl in my home after her death?"

Elise looked at me with an expression of profound, aching sorrow.

May you like

"Because Clara knew she was being murdered, Julian. And she didn't know who she could trust to protect her daughters."

***

Related Stories

Other posts