inquest

Chapter 8 - Day in Court

The Franklin County Court of Common Pleas was packed to capacity on Wednesday morning.

Reporters from three local news networks occupied the front two rows of the gallery, laptops humming, cameras trained on the heavy wooden doors of the holding cell.

Audrey Vance sat in the front row of the victim’s section, dressed in an immaculate, tailored charcoal suit. Stephen Vance sat beside her, whispering quiet instructions as court personnel shuffled stacks of docket sheets.

The side door opened, and a bailiff led Richard and Ethan Vance into the room.

Both men were handcuffed and shackled at the ankles, the heavy steel chains clinking rhythmically against the linoleum floor. Richard looked broken, his shoulders stooped, his face pale and haggard. Ethan refused to look toward the gallery; his eyes were glued to the floor, his breath coming in shallow, frightened hitches.

Teresa sat alone in the fourth row, clutching a worn leather purse, her face obscured behind oversized sunglasses.

"All rise for the Honorable Judge Marcus Harrison," the bailiff intoned.

Judge Harrison, a no-nonsense jurist with thirty years on the bench, took his seat and adjusted his spectacles. He looked down at the case file with visible disdain.

"State of Ohio versus Richard Vance and Ethan Vance," Harrison announced. "We are here for a preliminary hearing on multiple felony indictments, including Aggravated Assault, Grand Theft of a Motor Vehicle, Extortion, Burglary, and Violation of a Temporary Protection Order."

The assistant county prosecutor, Rachel Vance-no relation, stood up. "Your Honor, the State is prepared to present evidence demonstrating an ongoing, violent campaign of intimidation and theft orchestrated by the defendants against the victim, Audrey Vance, occurring within hours of the burial of her late husband."

"Defense counsel?" Harrison looked toward the public defender assigned to the case after Richard’s private attorney withdrew due to non-payment.

"Your Honor," the defender began weakly, "my clients maintain that this was an unfortunate domestic misunderstanding regarding the distribution of estate assets during an emotional time—"

"A misunderstanding?" Judge Harrison interrupted, leaning forward over his bench. "Counsel, I have reviewed the video evidence submitted by the State. I would like the record to reflect what the court has seen."

The prosecutor touched a button on the lectern.

Two large flat-screen monitors mounted on the courtroom walls flickered to life.

The gallery gasped.

In crystal-clear 4K resolution, the entire tragedy played out before the court:

The rain pouring over Audrey’s driveway.

The cruel sneer on Ethan’s face as he caressed the hood of the Mercedes.

The audible sound of Richard’s voice: *"We also want his financial records and the deed to this house."*

The brutal, unprovoked backhand that sent Audrey crashing against the brick wall.

The sight of Richard dragging his grieving daughter by the coat collar across the concrete patio like a sack of garbage.

And finally, Richard’s venomous promise: *"We’ll be back on Friday for the deed. You’re completely alone now, Audrey."*

Teresa began to weep loudly in the fourth row. The bailiff immediately glared at her, holding up a finger for silence.

Richard kept his eyes squeezed shut, unable to look at the screen. Ethan began to tremble, silent tears dripping from his chin onto his orange jumpsuit.

"Turn that off," Judge Harrison ordered, his voice thick with suppressed fury.

The screens went black.

"In my thirty years on the bench," Harrison said, his eyes drilling into Richard Vance, "I have rarely witnessed such an abhorrent display of cowardly brutality and naked greed. You struck your daughter hours after she buried her husband. You attempted to extort the home she built. You violated a protection order while armed with an iron bar."

Harrison turned his gaze toward Ethan. "And you, Mr. Ethan Vance, took pleasure in stripping your sister of her transportation while your father assaulted her. You drove that stolen vehicle to a high-end restaurant to flaunt it on social media."

"Your Honor, please—" Ethan squeaked.

"Silence!" Harrison snapped. "The State’s motion to revoke bail for both defendants is GRANTED. Richard Vance, you will be held without bond pending trial. Ethan Vance, your bond is set at one hundred and fifty thousand dollars cash, fully secured."

Harrison banged his heavy wooden gavel. The crack echoed through the silent courtroom like thunder.

"Next case."

As the bailiffs hoisted Richard and Ethan to their feet to lead them back to the cells, Richard twisted his head toward Audrey.

Their eyes met across the wooden railing.

For years, that look would have made Audrey shrink into herself, terrified of the yelling, the guilt, the emotional manipulation that had governed her entire life.

Now, Audrey did not look away. She sat straight, her chin raised, her eyes filled with an absolute, unyielding coldness.

Richard’s lips moved silently, forming the word: *Please.*

May you like

Audrey did not blink. She watched him shuffle through the heavy steel door until the latch clicked shut.

***

Related Stories

Other posts